Erez Part 4: UMH Issued ~$1.08B of Stock While Paying ~$513M in Dividends
UMH is trading near its 52-week low of $13.93 (4.4% above the low).
Summary
Erez Asset Management released Part 4 of its campaign, arguing UMH has diluted shareholders roughly 8.4x over 20 years to fund a dividend it never covered with cash flow, and confirmed plans for a 2027 proxy fight for Board seats.
Key Events · Ownership and Investor Activity · UMH
-
Erez Releases Fourth Campaign Installment
Erez Asset Management, which owns approximately 5.5% of UMH, published Part 4 of 'Right Horse, Wrong Jockey,' arguing UMH has sold stock for two decades to fund dividends it did not need and could not cover.
-
Dilution and Dividend Math Quantified
Erez says UMH issued roughly $1.08 billion of new common stock from 2006-2025 while paying about $513 million in dividends, roughly 82% of which was return of capital, and that shares outstanding grew from 10.2M to 85.6M (~8.4x).
-
Dividend Coverage Gap Versus Peers
The presentation claims the dividend exceeded FAD per share in 20 of 20 years, with cumulative payouts at ~154% of FAD versus ~78% for SUI and ~70% for ELS.
-
2027 Proxy Fight Confirmed
Erez, Erez REIT Opportunities Fund and Bruce Schanzer intend to file a definitive proxy statement seeking Board change at UMH's 2027 annual meeting; participants beneficially own 4,750,000 shares.
Analysis · UMH · Real Estate & Construction
Erez's fourth installment shifts from narrative attacks to a quantified capital-allocation case: roughly $1.08 billion of common stock issued from 2006-2025 against about $513 million of dividends paid, with roughly 82% of those distributions classified as return of capital. The sharpest argument yet that UMH funds its yield with new investors' money is the claim that the dividend exceeded funds available for distribution in 20 of 20 years, and that cumulative payouts ran ~154% of FAD versus ~78% and ~70% for peers SUI and ELS. Erez also confirms it will file a definitive proxy statement to seek Board change at the 2027 annual meeting, so this is a live proxy contest rather than commentary. The counterweight: UMH's Q3 2026 rental income rose 8% and total income of $74.1 million beat the $68.4 million estimate, so shareholders are being asked to weigh a governance critique against improving operations.
How filings like this one have moved
In the 30 days to Nov 12, 2026, 37% of the 3595 measured filings Wiseek scored 7 moved their stock by 5% or more by the next session's close. The median move was 0.00%. These are measured outcomes after filings of this importance, not a forecast for this one.
Measured one observation per ticker per day, after exclusions. Current figures: Filing Impact Tracker · open dataset
At the time of this filing, UMH was trading at $14.54 on NYSE in the Real Estate & Construction sector, with a market capitalization of approximately $1.2B. The 52-week trading range was $13.93 to $16.77. This filing was assessed with negative market sentiment and an importance score of 7 out of 10.