Otter Tail 10-Q: Q3 EPS $1.41, Nine-Month Net Income Halved by $103.5M PVC Settlement
OTTR is trading near its 52-week low of $74.15 (14% above the low).
Summary
Otter Tail's Q3 10-Q confirms the already-reported $1.41 EPS and shows nine-month net income cut to $124.5 million by a $103.5 million PVC settlement charge, now fully paid after appeals expired. Capital spending nearly doubled to $451.6 million, funded with $170 million of new debt.
Key Events · Earnings and Guidance · OTTR
-
Q3 EPS $1.41, Down From $1.86
Third-quarter diluted EPS was $1.41 versus $1.86 a year ago; net income fell to $59.5 million from $78.3 million on weaker Plastics pricing and higher electric O&M.
-
$103.5M PVC Settlement Now Final
Nine-month results include a $103.5 million pre-tax legal settlement charge. All three settlement agreements received final court approval and every appeal period expired with no appeals, releasing the escrowed restricted cash and satisfying the obligation.
-
Tax Benefit Offsets Part of Charge
Nine-month income tax swung to an $11.8 million benefit from $36.6 million of expense, including $26.3 million of discrete benefits tied to the settlement losses.
-
Capex Nearly Doubles to $451.6M
Nine-month capital expenditures rose to $451.6 million from $213.3 million, with $429.3 million in the Electric segment for the Abercrombie and Solway solar projects, funded partly by $170.0 million of new OTP long-term notes.
Analysis · OTTR · Energy & Transportation
The headline numbers were already out on November 2, but the full 10-Q fills in what the press release only sketched. Nine-month net income fell to $124.5 million from $224.1 million, and essentially all of that drop is the $103.5 million pre-tax charge for the PVC pipe antitrust settlements — a one-time cash hit, not an operating deterioration. That cash has now left escrow: all three settlements won final court approval and every appeal window closed with no appeals filed, so the liability is extinguished. Two items deserve attention. First, capital spending nearly doubled to $451.6 million from $213.3 million, with $429.3 million in the Electric segment for the Abercrombie and Solway solar projects — that spending is what drove $170 million of new long-term debt and a $3.6 million rise in nine-month interest expense. Second, OTP's total capitalization of $2.5 billion now sits above the $2.4 billion MPUC-authorized ceiling, and the company has asked for temporary permission to exceed it; that is a regulatory constraint to track alongside the Minnesota rate case, where the requested increase was trimmed to $38.7 million and a final order is expected in April 2027.
How filings like this one have moved
In the 30 days to Nov 17, 2026, 38% of the 3791 measured filings Wiseek scored 7 moved their stock by 5% or more by the next session's close. The median move was 0.00%. These are measured outcomes after filings of this importance, not a forecast for this one.
Measured one observation per ticker per day, after exclusions. Current figures: Filing Impact Tracker · open dataset
At the time of this filing, OTTR was trading at $84.70 on NASDAQ in the Energy & Transportation sector, with a market capitalization of approximately $3.6B. The 52-week trading range was $74.15 to $95.09. This filing was assessed with neutral market sentiment and an importance score of 7 out of 10.