NI Holdings Swings to Q3 Profit; Combined Ratio Improves to 93.6%
NODK sits 24% above its 52-week low of $12.37.
Summary
NI Holdings earned $5.5 million, or $0.27 per share, in Q3 2026 versus a $1.7 million loss a year ago, as the combined ratio improved to 93.6% from 109.1%. Premiums still shrank 7.2% amid the company's exit from Non-Standard Auto.
Updates
· GlobeNewswire — NI Holdings reported Q3 2026 net premiums earned fell 8.6% to $65,756 thousand and the loss and LAE ratio improved to 64.1% from 78.2%, down 14.1 points.
- Q3 Profitability — Q3 combined ratio was 93.6% versus 109.1%, improved 15.5 pts; Q3 expense ratio 29.5% versus 30.9%, down 1.4 points; Q3 return on average equity 9.0% versus (2.7%).
- Nine-Month Results — Nine-month net income $18,182 thousand versus $(7,257) thousand net loss; combined ratio 94.4% versus 110.0%, down 15.6 pts; loss and LAE ratio 61.3% versus 76.0%, down 14.7 pts; expense ratio 33.1% versus 34.0%, down 0.9 points; basic EPS $0.87 versus $(0.35); return on average equity 10.0% versus (4.0%).
- Premiums — Nine-month net premiums earned fell 12.5% to $185,886 thousand; nine-month gross premiums written fell 8.0% to $219,049 thousand.
- Investment Income — Q3 net investment income $2,716 thousand, down 10.7%; nine-month net investment income fell 9.3% to $8,181 thousand; Q3 net investment gains (losses) $(93) thousand versus $1,362 thousand; nine-month net investment gains $3,674 thousand versus $1,821 thousand.
- Segment Premiums
- All Other gross premiums written rose 50.6% due to continued increased assumed premiums from participation on catastrophe reinsurance programs of certain farm bureau insurance companies
- Home and Farm gross premiums written rose 1.9% due to strong renewal premiums, rate increases and increased new business in North Dakota
- Private Passenger Auto decline due to lower new business and renewal premiums in South Dakota and Nebraska and rate decreases in North Dakota, South Dakota and Nebraska
- Loss Drivers — Higher Crop losses due to North Dakota drought; increased large loss activity and adverse prior year development on loss reserves in Private Passenger Auto.
All 19 details
- Q3 net investment gains (losses) $(93) thousand versus $1,362 thousand in Q3 2025
- Nine-month net investment gains $3,674 thousand versus $1,821 thousand
- Nine-month net premiums earned fell 12.5% to $185,886 thousand
- Nine-month gross premiums written fell 8.0% to $219,049 thousand
- Nine-month expense ratio 33.1% versus 34.0%, down 0.9 points
- Nine-month net investment income fell 9.3% to $8,181 thousand
- Nine-month basic EPS $0.87 versus $(0.35)
- Q3 return on average equity 9.0% versus (2.7%)
- Nine-month return on average equity 10.0% versus (4.0%)
- Q3 expense ratio 29.5% versus 30.9%, down 1.4 points
- All Other gross premiums written rose 50.6% due to continued increased assumed premiums from participation on catastrophe reinsurance programs of certain farm bureau insurance companies
- Home and Farm gross premiums written rose 1.9% due to strong renewal premiums, rate increases and increased new business in North Dakota
- Private Passenger Auto decline due to lower new business and renewal premiums in South Dakota and Nebraska and rate decreases in North Dakota, South Dakota and Nebraska
- Nine-month loss and LAE ratio 61.3% versus 76.0%, down 14.7 pts
- Nine-month combined ratio 94.4% versus 110.0%, down 15.6 pts
- Q3 combined ratio 93.6% versus 109.1%, improved 15.5 pts
- Nine-month net income $18,182 thousand versus $(7,257) thousand net loss
- Q3 net investment income $2,716 thousand, down 10.7%, due to lower average fixed income portfolio balance as maturities and sales proceeds funded Non-Standard Auto operating cash needs
- Higher Crop losses due to North Dakota drought; increased large loss activity and adverse prior year development on loss reserves in Private Passenger Auto
Key Events · Earnings and Guidance · NODK
-
Q3 Swings to $5.5M Profit
Net income of $5,528 thousand versus a $1,666 thousand loss in Q3 2025; basic EPS of $0.27 versus $(0.08).
-
Combined Ratio Improves 15.5 Points
The combined ratio of 93.6% versus 109.1% was driven by favorable prior-year reserve development in Non-Standard Auto and lower weather losses in Home and Farm.
-
Premiums Continue to Shrink
Gross premiums written fell 7.2% to $54,346 thousand, with Non-Standard Auto down 100.2% on the segment exit and Private Passenger Auto down 8.4%.
-
Crop and Auto Losses Offset Gains
Higher Crop losses from North Dakota drought and adverse prior-year development in Private Passenger Auto partially offset the improvement; net investment income fell 10.7% to $2.7 million.
Analysis · NODK · Finance
The headline swing to $5.5 million of net income in Q3 2026, from a $1.7 million loss a year ago, rests on a 15.5-point drop in the combined ratio to 93.6%. Favorable prior-year reserve development in Non-Standard Auto (now in runoff) and lower weather losses in Home and Farm drove the improvement, not growth: gross premiums written fell 7.2% to $54.3 million as the company exits Non-Standard Auto and trims Private Passenger Auto. Offsetting these gains were Crop losses from North Dakota drought and adverse Private Passenger Auto development. With nine-month net income of $18.2 million and a 94.4% combined ratio, the company is on track for its first solidly profitable year after a loss-making 2025, which is the core of the thesis here.
How filings like this one have moved
In the 30 days to Nov 8, 2026, 36.5% of the 3015 measured filings Wiseek scored 7 moved their stock by 5% or more by the next session's close. The median move was 0.00%. These are measured outcomes after filings of this importance, not a forecast for this one.
Measured one observation per ticker per day, after exclusions. Current figures: Filing Impact Tracker · open dataset
At the time of this filing, NODK was trading at $15.33 on NASDAQ in the Finance sector, with a market capitalization of approximately $312.8M. The 52-week trading range was $12.37 to $16.70. This filing was assessed with positive market sentiment and an importance score of 7 out of 10.